WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?
The noise levels on Carmine Street have escalated to a point where our peace of mind, quality of life and a
good nights rest are being negatively affected.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
Four years ago, Carmine Street was relatively quiet in evenings. You were able to come home from a hard day’s work and relax. Now, with the current noise level, that is impossible.
It starts in the early evening.
The bars/restaurants open their doors then loud music and conversation spills into the street. As the bars/restaurants fill up, the noise level rises significantly. Even after they close their doors, the problem continues.
The smokers extend their loud partying atmosphere onto the sidewalk. They are usually pretty drunk and therefore cannot understand that they are disturbing the (residents') peace. The rotation of smokers continues all through the night and each group usually contains a screamer.
When the bars/restaurants close, the last guests hang out in front, unsure where to go or to wait for a cab. This can take up to 30 minutes of yelling back and forth from the departing groups. If they cannot reach a decision, the benches in front of these establishments will serve as their destination before going home.
At this time, the garbage trucks arrive. It seems as though every establishment has their own service, so it could take some time before that ends.
When the last garbage truck finishes, we then are confronted with the patrons from surrounding area bars that closed at 4AM. They tend to gravitate to those same benches and the cycle of screaming, singing and loud talking resumes.
And just when you thought you finally can get some sleep, in comes the armada of delivery trucks. Most leave their engines idling while parked. We are subjected to slamming metal doors, beer kegs being dropped on the street and yelling between the truckers and restaurant/bar workers.
The above is an accurate description of what many Carmine Street residents have to deal with.
WHAT IS THE CAUSE?
a) Open door policy:
The noise from the bars is so loud that it seems as though the party is taking place in front of your window.
b) Unruly and inconsiderate patrons in front of the restaurants:
It is understandable that people can get loud outside of bars. One has to wonder why the patrons feel the need to talk loud/scream out on the sidewalk. The answer on Carmine Street is - because they can. The managers of these bars do nothing to limit the unnecessary noise from their customers.
c) Lack of repercussion:
There is no sense of responsibility from the restaurant/bar owners. Their lack of action shows a complete disregard for the residents.
HOW DOES IT AFFECT US?
The escalated noise levels are disturbing the peace on Carmine Street. Many of us are exhausted, stressed and frustrated with the current situation. We are being deprived of our sleep and feel that our quality of life has seriously deteriorated within the last 2 years. For more information on what excessive noise does to your health,
click here.
WHAT WOULD RESOLVE THE SITUATION?
a) If your restaurant/bar has a loud atmosphere, the doors should be closed.
b) Clearly visible signs
should be posted that inform patrons to respect the neighbors and control the volume of their voices.
c) Management must control the crowds/groups in front of their establishments. It should not be that residents have to ask these patrons to lower their voices and then be responded to with obscenities.
d) Outdoor benches should be removed at closing.
e) Faster and harsher response from the NYPD and the DEP.
We have no problem with people enjoying themselves on a night out, but it shouldn't be at our expense. There are a few venerable restaurants on this street that have served the neighborhood well. These restaurants have always displayed respect for the community. Some of the newer establishments clearly have not.
If you are affected by this, please get involved before our block loses its identity.
The time to act is now.
